Introducing a 2-Step Checkout to Boost Purchase Intent & Conversion

The Problem

Users were dropping off at a critical moment—the order page.

Exit rate: 56%, significantly higher than the industry average of ~25%

Users landed on the order page but didn’t convert

Top exiting reasons:

Cognitive overload: Pricing, payment, and order summary all on one cluttered screen

Lack of purchase intent: Some users might just want to check out the cost instead of committing to a plan

Low persuasive power: The page didn’t reaffirm why ExpressVPN was the right choice

Competitor Analysis

A competitor analysis revealed that most high-converting platforms used a 2-step checkout flow to reduce decision fatigue and qualify leads better.

Hypothesis

We believed that introducing a dedicated pricing step before the checkout form would:

Increase conversion rate and revenue per visitor

Lower refunds by attracting more intentional purchasers

We will know we are successful when

↑ Conversion Rate

↑ Revenue per Session

↓ Refunds (as we offer 30-day money-back guarantee)

Design Discovery

To better understand how to improve the flow, I led a "How Might We" workshop with stakeholders from product, marketing, and dev.

Problem A

Users are not sure if they really need a VPN and whether ExpressVPN is the right option or not.

How might we

Educate users why a VPN is crucial and how ExpressVPN is the right choice for them.

Problem B

The checkout experience is confusing. Pricing information and payment options are all in one page without a clear action guide.

How might we

Make our checkout flow simpler and more intuitive for users.

Problem C

Users just wanna checkout the plan and pricing details instead of having intension to checkout.

How might we

Showcase our plans clearly and increase users’ purchase intention.

Ideation & Wireframing

After those ideation sessions with the team, we explored directions that can

Showcase plans in a clear, digestible format

Introduce social proof and trust signals

Reinforce unique selling points before payment

Design Solution

After reviewing with different stakeholders, we decided to incorporate the following elements in our order page:

Step 1: Pricing Page

Clear plan comparisons

Top USPs to reaffirm value

Social proof

Step 2: Order Page

Cleaner layout focused only on payment

The final checkout flow

Conclusion

This has been an exciting project for me to work on because I was able to design a new checkout experience for ExpressVPN’s potential customers on such a crucial page that directly impacts business revenue.

Key learnings

Introducing a small amount of friction—a second step—actually improved user decision-making.

Reinforcement works. Highlighting benefits and trust signals just before the paywall reassures users.

Research-backed design wins trust. By aligning with user behavior and competitive norms, we designed an experience that converts.

Let's Connect!

Always down for collaborations. I love to make products even more meaningful.

© 2024. By Mandy Tam